Header shape illustration 1Header shape illustration 2
Back

Right Answer, Wrong Score: Uncovering the Inconsistencies of LLM Evaluation in Multiple-Choice Question Answering

Francesco Maria Molfese, Luca Moroni, Luca Gioffrè, Alessandro Scirè, Simone Conia, Roberto Navigli

Abstract

One of the most widely used tasks to evaluate Large Language Models (LLMs) is Multiple-Choice Question Answering (MCQA). While open-ended question answering tasks are more challenging to evaluate, MCQA tasks are, in principle, easier to assess, as the model's answer is thought to be simple to extract and is directly compared to a set of predefined choices. However, recent studies have started to question the reliability of MCQA evaluation, showing that multiple factors can significantly impact the reported performance of LLMs, especially when the model generates free-form text before selecting one of the answer choices. In this work, we shed light on the inconsistencies of MCQA evaluation strategies, which can lead to inaccurate and misleading model comparisons. We systematically analyze whether existing answer extraction methods are aligned with human judgment, and how they are influenced by answer constraints in the prompt across different domains. Our experiments demonstrate that traditional evaluation strategies often underestimate LLM capabilities, while LLM-based answer extractors are prone to systematic errors. Moreover, we reveal a fundamental trade-off between including format constraints in the prompt to simplify answer extraction and allowing models to generate free-form text to improve reasoning. Our findings call for standardized evaluation methodologies and highlight the need for more reliable and consistent MCQA evaluation practices.
July 2025, Association for Computational Linguistics

Your privacy choices

Save and continue
Sign up!
The best way to get the latest news from Babelscape and the NLP world!
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Thank you for subscribing!
You’ve been added to our mailing list, and you’ll receive our next newsletter to stay updated on the latest news from the NLP world!
Something went wrong
We are sorry, your request cannot be processed right now.
Please wait a bit and try again.
Unsubscribe
We're sorry to see you go. Please enter your email address to complete the unsubscription process.
You'll receive an email confirmation shortly.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Check your email
We have sent you a link to your email to complete the unsubscribe process.
Something went wrong
We are sorry, your request cannot be processed right now.
Please wait a bit and try again.